Urban Wire Why the Wage Cap Matters for State Paid Family and Medical Leave
Jonathan Schwabish
Display Date

 Adult lifting toddler on play mat while another child sits at a table.

If Congress changes the Social Security taxable maximum, or the amount of earnings subject to payroll tax, the effects won’t stop at the federal level. Most state paid family and medical leave (PFML) programs are financed through payroll contributions and use the Social Security taxable maximum as the ceiling on earnings subject to the tax. As lawmakers weigh how to address Social Security’s projected trust fund shortfall before 2032, states may need to reevaluate how, and to what extent, their PFML financing should match federal policy.

Here is what states should be thinking about now to get ready.

How PFML programs are funded

Most state PFML programs operate as social insurance. Workers, employers, or both contribute through payroll contributions to a dedicated state fund. When an eligible worker takes leave for a covered reason, such as the birth or adoption of a child, caring for a seriously ill family member, or the worker’s own serious health condition, the fund pays a portion of their wages for a limited period. Because the money is collected and held separately from the state’s general budget, benefits are generally paid out of the program’s own revenue, rather than through annual appropriations.

Most state programs use the Social Security taxable maximum

As of October 2026, 14 states and Washington, DC, have enacted mandatory PFML programs or closely related social insurance programs. Ten of those states—Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Oregon, Virginia, and Washington—cap contributions at the Social Security taxable maximum or use a wage base directly tied to it. (Virginia’s program will begin collecting contributions in April 2028.)

In 2026, the Social Security taxable maximum is $184,500, which means that a worker earning $184,500 and a worker earning $500,000 pay the same amount in Social Security tax and the same maximum PFML contribution.

The remaining states take different approaches:

  • California eliminated the taxable-wage limit for its state disability and family leave program, which finances both disability and paid family leave. In 2026, the 1.3 percent employee contribution rate applies to all covered wages.
  • New Jersey and Rhode Island impose their own wage ceilings. In 2026, New Jersey workers’ Temporary Disability and Family Leave Insurance contributions apply to the first $171,100 of wages (with some additional details in the calculations, and different calculations for employers), while Rhode Island’s Temporary Disability and Temporary Caregiver Insurance tax applies to the first $100,000.
  • New York calculates employee contributions as a percentage of wages but caps the total amount a worker pays. In 2026, workers contribute 0.432 percent of gross wages, up to an annual maximum contribution of about $412.
  • Washington, DC, also applies its paid-leave tax without a wage ceiling, but its financing structure is unusual: It imposes the tax entirely on employers rather than deducting it from workers’ paychecks.

Who pays the contribution

States divide costs differently. California and New York rely on employee contributions. Other states split the contribution between workers and employers, sometimes with different treatment for small employers. DC falls on the other side of the spectrum, imposing the tax entirely on employers (though economists generally expect that some of any employer-paid share is eventually passed on to workers through lower wages [PDF]).

2026 premium rates for workers and employers
Body

Why the wage cap matters

The taxable wage ceiling determines who pays and how much revenue a program raises.

In Massachusetts, eligible employers pay a total contribution of 0.88 percent of workers’ earnings up to the Social Security taxable maximum. Employers may withhold up to 0.46 percent from employee wages and pay the balance themselves (PDF). A worker earning at the taxable maximum of $184,500 would pay $849 in taxes; a worker earning twice that ($369,000) would pay the same amount because anything earned over the cap is not taxed.

Absent state action, if the Social Security taxable maximum were eliminated, for example as Sens. Moreno (R-OH) and Warren (D-MA) have proposed, a worker earning twice the taxable maximum would then see their PFML taxes double to $1,697, in addition to owing more Social Security taxes.

The policy trade-offs

Expanding or eliminating the Social Security taxable maximum would raise more revenue by requiring higher-income workers to pay taxes on a higher share of their earnings. States could use the revenue to lower contribution rates for all workers, fund more-generous benefits, or build a larger reserve. As an example, California chose to fund more-generous benefits: In 2022 it eliminated its taxable wage cap (effective 2024) to finance higher wage replacement rates starting in 2025.

But policymakers will need to weigh the trade-offs. On one hand, higher payroll taxes could slow economic growth or lead higher-earning workers to seek other places to live. On the other hand, providing paid leave itself might affect economic growth through changes in labor force participation and migration patterns if workers move to states with paid leave.

Most state PFML programs are fiscally healthy and stable, largely because of the dedicated payroll tax stream with statutory switches that require annual adjustments to protect solvency. Changes to the PFML taxable wage bases also affect dedicated funds, rather than general state funds, which eliminates the possibility of raising revenue for general funds and other programs. If federal policymakers decide to expand or eliminate the Social Security taxable maximum or make larger changes to the Social Security system—such as expanding the definition of earnings to include more nonearnings forms of compensation—states will need to decide whether and how their PFML programs should follow.

Financing choices are not fixed. Several states adjust their contribution rates from year to year (PDF) based on the balance of the fund, the cost of benefits, tax rates, and wage ceilings that are tied to the Social Security taxable maximum. As newer programs, such as Virginia’s, move toward collecting contributions and paying benefits, they will face the same questions as older programs: whether the rate is high enough to keep the fund solvent, who should pay it, and whether the amount of earnings subject to the tax should have a limit.

Research and Evidence Tax and Income Supports
Expertise Families
Tags Social Security Family and medical leave Family care and support Family savings Federal budget and economy Paid leave State programs, budgets
Related content