Urban Wire New research sheds light on America’s underground commercial sex economy
Kate Villarreal, Meredith Dank
Display Date

Media Name: ap320864680863.jpg

A massage parlor in Seattle, a high-end escort service in Dallas, a makeshift brothel in rural California, a clandestine Internet site—the underground commercial sex economy in America is diverse, organized, and lucrative, extending far beyond the typical street corner.

A new Urban Institute report and accompanying feature, based on research funded by the National Institute of Justice, is the first to estimate the monetary size of the underground commercial sex economy in US cities and to address its deep complexity. We now have scientifically rigorous cash estimates for the illicit commercial sex trade in Atlanta, Dallas, Denver, Miami, San Diego, Seattle, and Washington, DC.

Based on 260 interviews with both law enforcement personnel and participants, we have gained a better sense of how the sex trade operates today and how it has changed over the last decade, due in large part to the growing availability and rapid expansion of the Internet.

Here’s some of what we now know:

  • It’s sizable. The underground commercial sex trade brought in from $39.9 million in Denver to $290 million in Atlanta in 2007 alone.
  • It’s sophisticated. Our interviews with 73 convicted pimps and sex traffickers reveal operations that followed legitimate business plans, which included strategies for recruitment, advertising, travel, transportation, supplies, and other expenses. They also cultivated networks and business relationships with others involved in the trade.
  • It’s complex. We now have a much deeper understanding about who goes into the underground commercial sex trade and the different reasons why. Pimps spoke of growing up with family members in the business, being recruited by women to pimp, or segueing into the sex trade from selling drugs. Some felt they were well-suited for the business based on personality or even a propensity for manipulation.
  • It challenges stereotypes. We now have empirical evidence that calls into question existing myths about the sex trade. For instance, contrary to the stereotype of the physically abusive pimp, convicted pimps described a preference for using psychological manipulation instead, feigning romantic interest and promising material comforts to exploit perceived vulnerabilities in their employees.

So, what happens now? Prevention, for one. Though their roles are different, both offenders and victims can enter the underground commercial sex economy through similar pathways, and these pathways can begin in disadvantaged neighborhoods.  Now that we have a better sense of how and why people get involved, we can strengthen prevention efforts by investing in child welfare programs, schools, community programs, and more to ensure that young people have other options.

Intervention is also key. We need more resources and mandates for law enforcement and service providers not only to find, arrest, and convict sex traffickers, but also to provide services for those who want to leave the life, but have few alternatives.

We’ll have more to share from the report in the coming weeks. Please check back to our interactive feature for periodic updates.

Photo by LM Otero/AP


Tune in and subscribe today.

The Urban Institute podcast, Evidence in Action, inspires changemakers to lead with evidence and act with equity. Cohosted by Urban President Sarah Rosen Wartell and Executive Vice President Kimberlyn Leary, every episode features in-depth discussions with experts and leaders on topics ranging from how to advance equity, to designing innovative solutions that achieve community impact, to what it means to practice evidence-based leadership.


Research Areas Crime, justice, and safety
Tags Crime and justice analytics Policing and community safety