Research Report A Look at NextUp Implementation in California
Subtitle
Staff and Student Perspectives on a Campus Support Program for Students with Foster Care History
Laura Packard Tucker, Devlin Hanson, Jonah Norwitt, Annabel Stattelman-Scanlan
Display Date
File
File
Download
(584.11 KB)

NextUp is a campus support program for students with foster care history attending California community colleges who meet eligibility requirements. The program, which began in 2014, aims to provide participants with the academic, social, emotional, and financial supports they need to be successful at college. The 2022–23 California budget expanded NextUp by giving program funding to 69 additional community colleges. As of January 2023, 115 of the 116 California community colleges have been allocated program funds.

To learn more about NextUp implementation throughout California, including student experiences with the program, we conducted a statewide survey of NextUp staff, interviewed program coordinators, and held focus groups with NextUp participants.

Why This Matters

Most young people with foster care history want to pursue postsecondary education, but they face high tuition and living costs; a lack of financial, academic, and social support; and other barriers to attending and graduating from college. Campus support programs like NextUp can play a role in addressing the challenges faced by students with foster care history, but little is known about the program’s implementation and participant experiences.

What We Found

  • NextUp services: NextUp services primarily consist of financial assistance and counseling, but programs also offer community-building events, educational workshops, and tutoring. NextUp programs offer standard services like book vouchers and counseling, provide students with individualized support, and provide referrals to other services.
  • Outreach and engagement: NextUp programs conduct outreach to ensure that eligible students know about their services and to send out information about resources, opportunities, and events. More than 75 percent of programs surveyed conduct specialized outreach and have streamlined their recruitment and onboarding processes. Some students we spoke with recommended improving outreach to eligible students, but the majority were happy with their program’s communication about services, workshops, and other opportunities.
  • Student experiences: The vast majority of students spoke positively of NextUp’s services and staff. Students often mentioned that financial supports were especially helpful, including the NextUp grant, book vouchers, gas cards, and food cards. A few students had negative experiences with the NextUp program, mostly related to lackluster communication and a lack of community for virtual students.
  • NextUp implementation: NextUp’s program guidelines and individual campus environments both influenced implementation. Program coordinators described flexible guidelines as both an asset and a liability, allowing them to be responsive to the needs of their students but not providing enough guidance to instill confidence in their decisions. The campus context, including college leadership, NextUp staff members, and other programs on campus, played a major role in successful implementation. Successfully integrating NextUp with other programs for students with foster care history, receiving support from campus leadership, and coordinating between other programs and staff leaders on campus were all mentioned as important achievements.
  • Student success: NextUp program coordinators defined success based on short-term goals (such as retention or completing a class) rather than long-term goals (such as graduation) and emphasized that goals were student specific. Two of the nine programs specifically stated that “success isn’t about graduation—it's about retention.”

Despite its successes, the NextUp program has areas in which it could improve, especially given the variability across campuses in services, student experiences, and implementation. We recommend the following:

  • Provide more guidance on how to use NextUp funding without restricting the program’s flexibility.
  • Create resources to help NextUp staff navigate the challenges of integrating NextUp with existing programs.
  • Reconsider recommended staffing structure to ensure NextUp programs have sufficient staff.
  • Encourage more resources for engagement with and community building among students.
  • Develop new ways to engage with virtual students.
  • Ensure that each NextUp program has a physical program space.
  • Analyze and track long-term outcomes.

How We Did It

From April to May 2024, we conducted a survey of NextUp coordinators at all active NextUp programs across California. We received responses from 75 percent of NextUp programs, with 53 percent of responses coming from programs that first received funding after January 2023.

In May and early June, we conducted in-depth interviews with coordinators from nine randomly selected programs stratified by their urbanicity, location, and NextUp implementation status (i.e., new in the 2023–24 academic year or established before the 2023–24 academic year).

To understand the perspective of NextUp participants, we also conducted 13 virtual focus groups with 41 students participating in NextUp programs across the state. Students from 13 different campuses participated; 34 percent of students interviewed attended one of the campuses sampled for coordinator interviews.

Research and Evidence Family and Financial Well-Being Work, Education, and Labor Technology and Data
Expertise Higher Education Workforce Development Transition-Age Young People Early Childhood Child Welfare
Tags Beyond high school: Education and training Child welfare Foster care Higher education Transition-age youth Community colleges Children and youth Data analysis Data collection Qualitative data analysis
States California