Article California Required Affordable Housing Providers to Offer Rent Reporting Services. Did It Increase Take-Up?
Brett Theodos, Daniel Teles, Amanda Hermans
Display Date

 San Diego architecture and design

In recent years, rent reporting has gained attention as a tool to improve renters’ credit profiles. For most tenants, rent is their largest monthly expense. But rent payments are not traditionally reported to the major credit bureaus, so renters who pay on time do not receive a credit score benefit like homeowners do for mortgages.

Rent reporting, a financial service that reports rental payments to at least one of the three major credit bureaus, closes this gap. Previous research has demonstrated benefits of this practice for people with poor credit or little history of using credit products who remain in their apartments and pay rent on time. Our randomized-control trial, for example, found positive-only rent reporting increased both the likelihood of having a credit score at all and the likelihood of having a credit score above 600.

To encourage the practice, some state and local governments have explored rent reporting pilots. In 2020, California became the first state to require that affordable housing providers offer rent reporting to their residents. The law, which took effect in July 2021, applies to all affordable housing properties with at least 16 units. It requires that tenants are offered the option to have their rent reported to at least one consumer reporting agency. In 2024, California extended the requirement to all rental properties (affordable and market rate) with at least 16 units and made the requirement permanent for affordable housing.

Now, five years into the initial implementation, has rent reporting increased? To answer that question, we looked at rates of rent reporting in affordable housing in California before and after the law. We find that California affordable housing residents have experienced modest growth in rent reporting compared with Californians living outside of affordable housing and affordable housing residents in other states.

Did Rent Reporting Go Up?

Rent reporting grew dramatically among renters of affordable housing in California after the passage of the 2020 law. In January 2020, we identified 4,029 people with addresses in affordable housing buildings in California and with open rent trades on their credit file. In July 2024, 27,642 people with addresses in affordable housing buildings had open rent trades. Over that period, the share of credit-visible renters in affordable housing properties with open rent trades rose from 1.1 percent to 4.8 percent.

Rent reporting grew faster in affordable housing rentals than in market-rate rentals in California during this period, suggesting that the law had an effect. Our estimates show that similar renters in market-rate housing in California also increased their use of rent reporting but at half the rate of renters in affordable rental units. Using this comparison group, we estimate that living in affordable housing in California increased the likelihood of participation in rent reporting by 2.4 percentage points.

 

Source: Authors’ analysis of credit data provided by a major credit bureau.

Note: The estimated share is defined as the share of renters in affordable housing in California minus the estimated effect that living in affordable housing had on the probability that each person had an open rental trade at each point in time. We calculate the effects using an augmented inverse propensity weighting model and a comparison group of tenants not in affordable properties drawn from ZIP codes with affordable housing in California.

Body

Interestingly, however, we find a much smaller difference when we compare the experience of California renters in affordable housing to tenants in affordable housing in other states. Among credit-visible people living in affordable housing, we estimate that living in California increased the likelihood that someone participated in rent reporting by only half a percentage point. This difference is still statistically significant, but it only emerges in 2024.

Source: Authors’ analysis of credit data provided by a major credit bureau.

Note: The estimated share is defined as the share of renters in affordable housing in California minus the estimated treatment effect at each point in time. We calculate the treatment effects by estimating the effect of living in California on the likelihood of having an open rental trade using an augmented inverse propensity weighting model and a comparison group made up of renters in affordable housing in other states. We exclude Delaware and Colorado from the comparison group because of contemporaneous rent reporting pilots in those states.

Body

Although our estimates show that affordable housing units in California did have higher take-up of rent reporting, a few additional factors limit our ability to fully identify the scale of the law’s effect:

  • Efforts by third-party rent reporting companies. Our interviews suggested that some housing providers became aware of the state requirement through rent reporting firms, which collect rental payment information from property managers before reformatting and sharing this information with the credit bureaus. (Notable firms in this space include Esusu, Piñata, IDIQ, Bilt, Self, and Boom.) The law may have led these companies to direct outreach more toward affordable housing tenants and away from market-rate tenants, which could have depressed rent reporting growth in market-rate housing in California. The law may also have led third-party rent reporting companies to adopt similar outreach in other states, thus increasing rent reporting uptake outside of California.
  • Other federal, state, and local policies. Although their efforts are less widespread than the efforts in California, other state and local governments have sought to increase rent reporting in affordable housing. We excluded from our comparison group two states with notable pilot efforts: Delaware and Colorado. However, the accumulated effect of smaller initiatives may be driving the uptick in rent reporting in the affordable housing sample. Additionally, federal efforts, such as a 2021 Freddie Mac rent reporting incentive for multifamily borrowers, a 2022 rent reporting pilot program run by Fannie Mae, and the pilot within HUD’s Moving to Work Asset Building Cohort could have increased take-up.
  • Spillover effects from regional or national housing providers. Interviewees reported that some property managers or owners with national portfolios implemented rent reporting across all their properties. It is possible that the legislation in California spurred greater take-up in affordable housing beyond California. At the same time, rent reporting across all market segments expanded faster outside of California, with rent reporting growth between 2020 and 2024 higher in 45 other states. As such, California’s legislation could have spilled over to other states, or growth rates in other states could have spilled over to California, leading us to believe any net effect here is probably small.
  • Mission-based incentive. Because many affordable housing providers are mission-based, they may have offered rent reporting to tenants more quickly than their market-rate counterparts.

Why Didn’t the Rent Reporting Mandate Have Larger Effects?

After the statewide mandate, rent reporting in affordable properties increased in California relative to two comparison groups, but the change was modest, likely because of reasons related to the law’s design and implementation.

First, the law requires an affirmative opt-in from tenants to begin reporting rental payments, but housing providers did not provide consistent explanations of rent reporting and the opt-in process to tenants. Some stakeholders we spoke with suggested that an opt-out program, in which tenants were enrolled automatically unless they requested not to be would better boost enrollment. In the absence of an opt-out policy, increased resources for tenant education around the potential benefits of rent reporting may help to increase take-up.

Second, the law included no incentives for participation, no funding for outreach or awareness, and no repercussions for violating the mandate. To minimize opposition, the law was designed to have no budget, enforcement mechanism, or assigned oversight agency, and to sunset after four years.

Third, we heard that the lack of state funding for outreach and engagement may have hindered the law’s reach. Some affordable housing providers reported that they did not know about the law or its requirements, even if their organizations offered rent reporting services. Rent reporting rates in California began to pull ahead of other states in 2024, which suggests that the effects of the policy may have lagged. Our interviews suggested that by 2025 most affordable housing providers were offering rent reporting, but compliance was still far from universal. With more time and a greater push for awareness statewide, California’s rent reporting rate may continue to surpass those in other states.

Fourth, the law took effect during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, when many in the housing sector were focused on new regulations around eviction moratoriums and rental relief programs. This timing may have diverted attention from the new rent reporting regulations.

Finally, rent reporting adoption may be driven in part by the type of housing that’s available. For example, we found that rent reporting is more prevalent in states with more new large multifamily housing, possibly because properties that are owned or managed by companies with more advanced payment and data tracking systems are more likely to offer the service. California’s multifamily growth from 2020 to 2024 falls near the median among all states.

What’s Next for Rent Reporting?

In 2024, California passed two laws that extended and expanded the original law. The new laws applied the mandate to all housing developments with 16 or more units and eliminated the sunset date in the original law, extending the mandate indefinitely.

Rent reporting firms have responded by offering services specifically designed to meet the laws’ requirements. We heard that these efforts will likely lead to spillover in other states, as housing providers and property management companies begin to offer these services across their full portfolios.

For policymakers interested in encouraging rent reporting, some key decisions need to be made around the right approach. A mandate like California’s appears to have increased rent reporting, but policymakers could strengthen similar efforts through allocated resources for enforcement or education.

Other key considerations for those considering rent reporting laws include the following:

  • Will the policy affect all landlords and renters, or will it target a particular housing segment?
  • Should all rent payment activity (including missed payments) be reported or should reports be limited to only positive activity?
  • Will renters be automatically enrolled or will they need to opt-in?
  • Who will cover the costs of rent reporting services?

In addition to or in place of a mandate, states can issue guidance, guardrails, or renter protections. For example, proposed legislation in New York would require landlords to provide renters with certain information before reporting rent to credit bureaus and would cap the monthly service fees that could be passed on to renters at $5 (California capped their fee at $10). Future regulations could also consider requiring that rental payments be reported to all three major credit bureaus, rather than just one. Finally, we heard a need for standard guidance on how to format and report rental data to credit bureaus.

As rent reporting continues to grow as a mechanism to support renters’ credit building, California’s law shows that state-level legislation can affect rent reporting rates for affordable housing residents.

How We Did It

To measure the law’s effect on rent reporting access, we acquired anonymized microdata from a major credit bureau. We also collected and standardized address data from the National Housing Preservation Database, the US Department of Housing and Urban Development’s (HUD’s) Low Income Housing Tax Credit Database, and HUD’s Public Housing Buildings database to identify affordable housing buildings across the country.

We sent the addresses of the affordable housing buildings to the credit bureau, who then returned anonymized credit data for people whose addresses were in those affordable housing buildings. We also received anonymized data for renters in California that did not live in affordable housing, but who lived in the same ZIP codes as the affordable housing buildings.

Using the anonymous credit data, we tracked the growth of rent reporting among renters in affordable housing buildings in California. We first estimated the effect of the policy by comparing the renters living in affordable housing in California with renters living in market-rate housing in the same ZIP codes. Then, we estimated the effect by comparing the renters living in affordable housing in California with renters living in affordable housing in other states.

For both sets of estimates, we used Augmented Inverse Probability Weighting, which combines matching and regression methods. For covariates in the model, we used binary indicators for whether the individual had any of the following in their credit file in January of 2020: a rent reporting tradeline; a credit score; a credit score over 600, 660, or 780; open accounts of various types (auto, student, credit, installment, and revolving); an account of each type with a current balance; past due accounts; delinquent accounts; collections; and bankruptcies.

In our analysis, we only included data from one major credit bureau. The overall rate of rent reporting will therefore be higher than what we calculate. Meaningful differences in the approach to rent reporting between properties covered by the law and those that are not could also mean that we under- or overestimate the effect of the policy, but our interviews did not surface any such differences

We interviewed three groups of stakeholders: those involved with the passage of California’s law, housing providers and managers in California, and those involved in rent reporting programs and legislation in other states. We sought to understand the legislative process in California, how housing providers offered rent reporting, to what extent and why tenants opted in to rent reporting, and the impact of doing so. We also asked about whether and how this policy affected other rent reporting initiatives across the country.

 


 

This research was funded by Kaiser Permanente via a grant to Credit Builders Alliance. We are grateful to them and to all our funders, who make it possible for Urban to advance its mission. The views expressed are those of the authors and should not be attributed to the Urban Institute, its trustees, or its funders. Funders do not determine research findings or the insights and recommendations of our experts. More information on our funding principles is available here.

Research and Evidence Housing and Communities
Expertise Housing
Tags Community development finance and CDFIs Credit availability Family credit and debt Rental housing Community and economic development Data analysis Family and household data Housing and the economy Multifamily housing Quantitative data analysis State programs, budgets
States California